Why Calling Daryl Gates a Gold Standard Backfired on Nithya Raman in the LA Race

Why Calling Daryl Gates a Gold Standard Backfired on Nithya Raman in the LA Race

One slip of the tongue at a debate podium can turn a policy argument about ICE into a full-blown crisis over Los Angeles policing history. That's what happened when Nithya Raman and Karen Bass clashed over federal immigration enforcement and brought former LAPD Chief Daryl Gates straight into the spotlight.

If you're trying to make sense of why this clash got so heated so fast, here's the short version. Raman was trying to talk about LAPD non-cooperation with immigration enforcement—specifically Special Order 40—and invoked the Gates era as a "gold standard". Bass pounced on the remark, framing it as deep insensitivity toward a chief remembered for aggressive policing, surveillance abuses, and the fallout surrounding the 1992 Los Angeles riots. For an alternative look, see: this related article.

Look closely at what happened, though, and you'll see two distinct fights tangled together. One is a bitter debate over how L.A. handles Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and federal agents. The other is a raw nerve over who gets to define Los Angeles's policing past—and what that history means for the city's leadership right now.

How ICE Clashes Collided With Daryl Gates History

Immigration enforcement in Los Angeles has never been a neat, technical policy question. When federal immigration sweeps and protests hit the city, residents want to know whether local police are protecting immigrant neighborhoods or clearing the way for federal agents. Related reporting on the subject has been provided by The New York Times.

During an October 2026 mayoral debate, Raman pointed to L.A.'s history of non-cooperation with immigration enforcement and referenced the era of former chief Daryl Gates as a "gold standard". On paper, she was pointing toward Special Order 40, the 1979 LAPD directive barring officers from initiating stops solely to check a person's immigration status so crime victims and witnesses wouldn't stay silent out of fear of deportation.

In politics, though, context doesn't travel well in a soundbite. Hearing "Daryl Gates" paired with "gold standard" set off alarms immediately. Gates led the LAPD from 1978 to 1992, a period defined in many Angelenos' minds by heavy-handed sweeps like Operation Hammer, the unlawful surveillance exposed in the CAPA v. Gates litigation, the brutal beating of Rodney King, and the unrest that followed his resignation in 1992.

Calling any part of Daryl Gates's tenure a "gold standard" hits a historical fault line in Los Angeles, even if the speaker meant a narrow immigration rule.

Once Bass seized on the comment, the argument shifted from immigration tactics to historical judgment. Bass and her allies accused Raman of glossing over a painful chapter in Black and brown communities' history with the LAPD. Raman pushed back hard, calling Gates "an abhorrent and racist police chief," accusing Bass of twisting her words, and apologizing both publicly and in private meetings with community leaders for invoking his name.

What People Miss About Special Order 40 and Sanctuary Rules

A lot of commentators treat Special Order 40 like an ironclad shield against ICE. Honestly, that's a misconception that trips people up all the time.

Special Order 40 was adopted in 1979—under Mayor Tom Bradley and with Gates at the helm of the department—to stop LAPD officers from acting as de facto immigration investigators during routine police work. The logic was practical as well as humanitarian: if people are afraid a call to 911 will end in deportation, witnesses disappear and violent offenders walk free.

Still, Special Order 40 has limits. It governs LAPD officer conduct, not federal immigration authorities operating in the city. Over the years, advocates have argued that non-cooperation requires clearer rules around city resources, data sharing, and interactions with federal agencies—which is why Los Angeles also adopted a separate 2024 sanctuary-city ordinance restricting the use of city resources for immigration enforcement.

That distinction matters when politicians argue over ICE. You can support Special Order 40 and still clash fiercely over how the department handles protests, crowd control, surveillance tools, or federal requests today. For example, even while trading barbs over Gates and ICE, both Bass and Raman voiced opposition to LAPD's ties with license-plate-reader vendor Flock Safety, showing that overlapping concerns don't stop fierce political warfare.

Why This Fight Matters Beyond the Soundbites

This isn't just inside-baseball campaign theater. Policing choices in Los Angeles carry massive stakes for civil rights, public safety, and institutional trust.

When leaders debate ICE and LAPD accountability, they're really arguing over three practical questions:

  • Trust in reporting crime: Will immigrant residents report assaults, theft, or domestic abuse without worrying about federal fallout?
  • Command accountability: How closely do civilian leaders and police commissioners supervise specialized units and street operations?
  • Institutional stability: How do you push major reforms without breaking day-to-day operations or major city planning?

That last point became especially sharp as the conversation turned to LAPD leadership and major city milestones. With Los Angeles preparing to host the 2028 Olympic and Paralympic Games, questions about police leadership—including whether Chief Jim McDonnell stays on or gets replaced through the Board of Police Commissioners—became tied directly to arguments over immigration enforcement and readiness. Bass warned that removing the chief ahead of the 2028 Games would create disarray, while Raman's pledge to scrutinize and potentially replace leadership tapped into frustration from critics who felt the LAPD fell short on immigration enforcement.

Common Mistakes When Reading Political Clashes Like This

When two high-profile figures trade accusations over policing and ICE, it's easy to pick a side before checking the receipts. A few traps are worth avoiding:

  1. Mistaking a policy reference for a full endorsement: Politicians frequently name-check an era or an ordinance to make a narrow point and get burned when the broader history carries heavy baggage.
  2. Treating "non-cooperation" as a single fixed rule: Non-cooperation ranges from basic limits on status checks under Special Order 40 to broader restrictions on city resources and data.
  3. Ignoring how mayors actually control the LAPD: A mayor doesn't simply snap their fingers and fire a police chief unilaterally; appointments and removals run through the Board of Police Commissioners and City Council dynamics.

If you want to cut through the spin next time you hear leaders spar over ICE and LAPD history, check the primary records first. Read the text of Special Order 40 and Los Angeles's sanctuary ordinance rather than relying on debate clips. Look up historical assessments like the Christopher Commission findings or FRONTLINE's LAPD archives to understand why Daryl Gates remains such a polarizing figure. Finally, track Board of Police Commissioners agendas and official LAPD policy updates so you're watching actual rules and oversight—not just campaign rhetoric.

EP

Elena Parker

Elena Parker is a prolific writer and researcher with expertise in digital media, emerging technologies, and social trends shaping the modern world.